no fault auto insurance http://michiganradio.org en Auto no-fault overhaul is GOP’s ‘Holy Grail’ http://michiganradio.org/post/auto-no-fault-overhaul-gop-s-holy-grail <p>A political controversy in Lansing that just won’t die is back: <a href="http://michiganradio.org/post/few-issues-reveal-political-divide-auto-insurance">auto no-fault insurance</a>. There is yet <a href="http://michiganradio.org/post/gop-lawmakers-try-revive-no-fault-overhaul">another Republican effort</a> to muscle through an auto no-fault overhaul, this time being led by state House Speaker Jase Bolger.</p><p>There’s a lot in this proposal, released just yesterday, but one of the main things is a cap on the state’s currently unlimited medical benefits if you are injured in a crash. Under the Bolger plan, these benefits would top out at $10 million. Other parts of the proposal include limits on hospital fees and payments for in-home care, incentives to avoid litigation, and a guaranteed rate rollback in the first two years of coverage.</p><p>Essentially, there is something in this plan for all of the special interests that have a stake in the auto no-fault system – hospitals, insurance companies, trial lawyers – to dislike. But, Bolger says, bring it on. Fri, 21 Feb 2014 20:44:01 +0000 Zoe Clark & Rick Pluta 16550 at http://michiganradio.org Auto no-fault overhaul is GOP’s ‘Holy Grail’ GOP lawmakers try to revive no-fault overhaul http://michiganradio.org/post/gop-lawmakers-try-revive-no-fault-overhaul <p>At the state Capitol, House Speaker Jase Bolger, R-Marshall, says he still hopes to get an overhaul of Michigan’s no-fault auto insurance law through the Legislature this year.&nbsp; He rolled out a new plan to end Michigan’s unlimited lifetime medical benefits coupled with the promise of a rate reduction.</p><p></p><p>“We do seek to ensure more drivers, make our auto insurance more affordable,” said Bolger at a news conference to announce the proposal.</p><p></p> Fri, 21 Feb 2014 03:43:47 +0000 Rick Pluta 16539 at http://michiganradio.org GOP lawmakers try to revive no-fault overhaul Abortion, issue ads, Medicaid expansion could see legislative action in December http://michiganradio.org/post/abortion-issue-ads-medicaid-expansion-could-see-legislative-action-december <p></p><p>It could be a busy December for state lawmakers after they return from their Thanksgiving break.</p><p></p><p>Here are some of the issues that could come up for debate before the end of the year.</p><p></p><p></p><p><strong>Paying for the Medicaid expansion delay – </strong>In a procedural vote earlier this year, state lawmakers delayed by about two months the implementation of Michigan’s Medicaid expansion law. In doing so, they created a hole in the budget of more than $70 million.</p><p></p> Fri, 29 Nov 2013 11:30:31 +0000 Jake Neher 15472 at http://michiganradio.org Abortion, issue ads, Medicaid expansion could see legislative action in December Few issues reveal the political divide like auto insurance… http://michiganradio.org/post/few-issues-reveal-political-divide-auto-insurance <p>Insurance sure is a hot political topic these days with hearings in Washington on the glitches with the <a>HealthCare.gov</a> website, and the recent fight in the Legislature over the <a href="http://michiganradio.org/post/tea-party-looks-fight-over-every-step-medicaid-expansion">Medicaid expansion</a>. So what better moment to re-kindle the controversy over Michigan’s auto insurance rates and the no-fault law?</p><p>Which is exactly what Governor Rick Snyder did this week when he re-started talks among the groups with an interest in an overhaul of the law. That includes doctors and hospitals, insurance companies, and trial lawyers – all major political players in Lansing.</p><p>And, certainly, people who’ve been injured in car and truck accidents have a big stake.</p><p>Auto insurance is intensely political. (So much so that some states even have elected insurance commissioners.) Pretty much everyone runs the risk of being hurt in a crash, and everyone who owns a vehicle - under Michigan’s no-fault insurance law - is supposed to carry liability coverage.</p><p>People are always upset by <a href="http://michiganradio.org/post/whats-behind-high-costs-michigan-auto-insurance-rates">insurance rates</a>, but none more so than people who live in cities with high premiums. Cities like Detroit and Flint. &nbsp;Insurance rates actually <a href="http://bridgemi.com/2013/03/auto-rates-drive-detroit-voters-into-hiding/">affect elections</a>. Some city dwellers use out-of-town addresses on their driver’s licenses and voter registration to get lower rates, which also means they don’t vote in local elections. Fri, 25 Oct 2013 20:05:43 +0000 Rick Pluta & Zoe Clark 15003 at http://michiganradio.org Few issues reveal the political divide like auto insurance… Michigan auto insurance might get an overhaul http://michiganradio.org/post/michigan-auto-insurance-might-get-overhaul <p>The Michigan Legislature is considering bills that would overhaul auto insurance in the state.</p><p>There are several aspects to this. Jake Neher with the Michigan Public Radio Network joined us today to help us wade through what has been proposed.&nbsp;</p><p><em>Listen to the full interview above.</em></p><p> Wed, 25 Sep 2013 21:16:41 +0000 Stateside Staff 14588 at http://michiganradio.org Michigan auto insurance might get an overhaul Michigan Secretary of State speaks out against insurance fraud http://michiganradio.org/post/michigan-secretary-state-speaks-out-against-insurance-fraud <p><span style="line-height: 1.5;">When it comes to trying to wiggle out of paying for auto insurance, the creativity of some Michigan drivers seems to know no bounds.</span></p><p>But to all of those drivers who think they&#39;re getting away with auto insurance fraud, the Michigan Secretary of State has a warning: &quot;We&#39;re on to you.&quot;</p><p>Secretary of State Ruth Johnson is announcing the creation of a task force to fight fraud in auto insurance all across Michigan.</p><p>Secretary of State Johnson joined us today from Lansing.</p><p><em>Listen to the interview above.</em></p><p> Tue, 17 Sep 2013 20:28:27 +0000 Stateside Staff 14459 at http://michiganradio.org Michigan Secretary of State speaks out against insurance fraud Changes in store for no-fault insurance coverage? http://michiganradio.org/post/changes-store-no-fault-insurance-coverage <p>The Michigan Supreme Court has set some new limits on expenses that can be claimed under auto no-fault insurance coverage by people injured in car crashes.&nbsp;</p><p>Kenneth Admire used handicapped-accessible vans since a 1987 auto accident. Three times before, his insurance company paid the entire cost of the modified vehicles.</p><p>This last time, though, the company said it would pay for the modifications, but Admire has to buy the van.</p> Fri, 24 May 2013 19:10:52 +0000 Rick Pluta 12729 at http://michiganradio.org Changes in store for no-fault insurance coverage? In this morning’s news: Democratic insurance reform, tax increase in Flint, state officer salaries http://michiganradio.org/post/morning-s-news-democratic-insurance-reform-tax-increase-flint-state-officer-salaries <p><strong>Detroit Democrats propose auto insurance reform</strong></p><p>Democratic state lawmakers from Detroit are proposing their own strategy to overhaul auto insurance in Michigan.</p><p>“The Democrats oppose Governor Snyder’s plan to cap insurance payouts for catastrophic injuries sustained in car accidents...Detroit caucus members say they’ll propose other measures, like requiring insurance companies to justify rate increases,” Michigan Radio’s Sarah Cwiek<a href="http://www.michiganradio.org/post/detroit-state-lawmakers-suggest-alternative-auto-insurance-changes"> reports.</a></p><p><strong>Flint’s EM recommends income tax increase</strong></p><p>Flint’s emergency manager says his budget plan for the next year is balanced, but he warns that without new tax revenue sources, the city will again fall into debt.</p><p>“[Emergency Manager Ed] Kurtz says the loss of grant funding and declining property tax revenues will leave the city millions of dollars in the hole each year through 2018. Kurtz says Flint needs to raise its city income tax rate. Otherwise, Kurtz says Flint will face another round of budget cuts, including to police and fire,” according to Michigan Radio’s <a href="http://www.michiganradio.org/post/flints-budget-balanced-multimillion-dollar-deficits-loom">Steve Carmody.</a></p><p><strong>Salaries for state officials expected to stay the same</strong></p><p>“A state salary commission is expected to recommend no salary hikes for the governor or legislators. Governor Rick Snyder and legislative leaders sent word they’re not seeking bigger paychecks. There could be a battle over judges’ salaries, though, when the State Officers Compensation Commission meets today. Some judges have asked for a bump after a 10-year salary freeze,” Rick Pluta reports.</p><p> Tue, 21 May 2013 11:20:01 +0000 Michigan Radio Newsroom 12656 at http://michiganradio.org In this morning’s news: Democratic insurance reform, tax increase in Flint, state officer salaries Detroit state lawmakers suggest alternative auto insurance changes http://michiganradio.org/post/detroit-state-lawmakers-suggest-alternative-auto-insurance-changes <p>State lawmakers from Detroit say they will put forth their own package of bills to overhaul m auto insurance in Michigan.</p><p>The Democrats oppose Governor Snyder’s plan to cap insurance payouts for catastrophic car accident injuries at $1 million.</p><p>Snyder and some Republicans say Michigan’s unique “no-fault insurance” policy bumps up Michiganders’ auto insurance premiums. They say their proposal will bring those rates down by $125 per vehicle for at least one year, with possible future savings.</p> Mon, 20 May 2013 22:34:10 +0000 Sarah Cwiek 12652 at http://michiganradio.org Detroit state lawmakers suggest alternative auto insurance changes Could changes to auto Personal Injury Protection cost more than they save? http://michiganradio.org/post/could-changes-auto-personal-injury-protection-cost-more-they-save <p></p><p>Some members of the legislature are once again proposing changes to no-fault auto insurance in Michigan. They say it will save auto owners money. Opponents say the plan is good for insurance companies, but not for accident victims.</p><p>Everybody seems to agree auto insurance in Michigan costs too much.</p><p>Governor Rick Snyder and the chairs of the <a href="http://www.misenategop.com/senators/Hune.asp?District=22">Senate</a> and <a href="http://gophouse.org/representatives/southeast/lund/">House</a> insurance committees explained the<a href="http://www.michigan.gov/snyder/0,4668,7-277-57577_57657-300452--,00.html"> latest plan</a> to reduce the cost.</p><p>“In this legislation it would specify that premium costs would come down by $125 per vehicle in the first year and then hopefully because of competition and other things could even see that increase in later years,” Governor Snyder said.</p><p>That one-year guarantee of savings would come because of a reduction in the Personal Injury Protection part of auto insurance. Mon, 13 May 2013 11:00:00 +0000 Lester Graham 12532 at http://michiganradio.org Could changes to auto Personal Injury Protection cost more than they save? Oakland Co. executive compares House speaker to Hitler http://michiganradio.org/post/oakland-co-executive-compares-house-speaker-hitler <p>One of Michigan’s most well-known Republicans has some harsh words for the state House GOP leader.</p><p>Oakland County Executive L. Brooks Patterson appeared today on the Michigan Public Television show “Off the Record.”&nbsp; Patterson said state House Speaker Jase Bolger has abused his power, and compared him to the leader of Nazi Germany. Fri, 03 May 2013 20:26:39 +0000 Rick Pluta 12409 at http://michiganradio.org Oakland Co. executive compares House speaker to Hitler State House panel set to move forward no-fault overhaul http://michiganradio.org/post/state-house-panel-set-move-forward-no-fault-overhaul-0 <p>A proposed overhaul of Michigan’s no-fault auto insurance system has cleared its first legislative hurdle. A state House panel passed the bill on a party-line vote, with Democrats all voting "no."</p><p>Right now, people who are severely injured in an auto accident can get unlimited lifetime medical benefits.</p><p>The legislation would cap those benefits at a million dollars.</p><p>Many people who testified against the bill said people who are already injured would lose benefits they were promised.</p> Fri, 03 May 2013 14:19:45 +0000 Jake Neher 12394 at http://michiganradio.org State House panel set to move forward no-fault overhaul In this morning's news: Auto insurance, wolf hunting, insurance for live-in partners http://michiganradio.org/post/mornings-news-auto-insurance-wolf-hunting-insurance-live-partners <p><strong>No-fault overhaul moves forward</strong></p><p>"A state House panel has voted on a bill to overhaul Michigan’s auto no-fault system. Right now, people who are severely injured in an auto accident can get unlimited lifetime medical benefits. The legislation would cap those benefits at $1 million," Jake Neher reports.</p><p><strong>House adopts wolf hunting bill</strong></p><p>"The state House has approved a measure that would allow an Upper Peninsula wolf hunt to go ahead regardless of a referendum on the question," Rick Pluta reports.</p><p><strong>Health insurance for live-in partners stays</strong></p><p>"A decision to provide health insurance to same-sex domestic partners of Michigan state government employees is intact. In an order released Thursday, the state Supreme Court unanimously declined to hear an appeal filed by Republican Attorney General Bill Schuette. The state health insurance plan covers non-family members who've lived continuously with state workers for at least a year," the Associated Press reports.</p><p> Fri, 03 May 2013 11:01:39 +0000 Emily Fox 12390 at http://michiganradio.org In this morning's news: Auto insurance, wolf hunting, insurance for live-in partners L. Brooks Patterson speaks out against changing Michigan's no-fault auto insurance http://michiganradio.org/post/l-brooks-patterson-speaks-out-against-changing-michigans-no-fault-auto-insurance <p>A proposed reform to Michigan’s <a href="http://www.michiganradio.org/post/lawmakers-introduce-controversial-no-fault-changes">no-fault auto insurance</a> is circulating in the Legislature.</p><p>Among other things, it would cap benefits for people who suffer severe injuries in auto accidents at $1 million.</p><p>Oakland County Executive L. Brooks Patterson has come out as a strong opponent to this legislation.</p><p>Patterson is still recovering from a serious auto accident he had last summer, and his driver, James Cram of Owosso, was paralyzed from the neck down.</p><p>In this interview with Jennifer White, Patterson talks about his opposition to the proposed legislation and his recovery.</p><p><em>You can listen to the full interview above.</em></p><p>Patterson wanted to be clear that he and his driver were working at the time of their accident.</p><p>Their medical bills are covered by worker's compensation, so Patterson says his opposition to changes to Michigan's no-fault insurance laws are not for his own benefit.</p><p>"Did the accident make me more aware and more sensitized to the plight of people who suffer from catastrophic injuries? Absolutely," he said.</p><p></p><p> Tue, 30 Apr 2013 21:39:20 +0000 Jennifer White & Mercedes Mejia 12356 at http://michiganradio.org L. Brooks Patterson speaks out against changing Michigan's no-fault auto insurance Lawmakers introduce controversial no-fault changes http://michiganradio.org/post/lawmakers-introduce-controversial-no-fault-changes <p>State lawmakers will start debating controversial changes to Michigan’s no-fault auto insurance system this week. State House Insurance Committee Chair Pete Lund introduced the legislation on Tuesday.</p><p>He says he expects to hold several committee hearings on the issue to give lawmakers time to understand and discuss it.</p><p>“I don’t know if in their time in Lansing they’re ever going to have an issue that’s quite as complicated as this. And there’s so many different pieces involved that it’s really going to take time for people to sit down, look it over, and figure it out.”</p> Wed, 24 Apr 2013 17:33:23 +0000 Jake Neher 12271 at http://michiganradio.org Lawmakers introduce controversial no-fault changes Commentary: What price reform? http://michiganradio.org/post/commentary-what-price-reform <p>Last week, Governor Snyder announced plans to drastically limit benefits for those terribly injured in catastrophic auto accidents. And, as expected, legislation to do that was introduced yesterday.</p><p>Acting on behalf of the governor, State Representative Pete Lund of Shelby Township introduced two bills that would radically change how much care the badly maimed can get.</p><p>Currently, those benefits are administered and paid by an agency called the Michigan Catastrophic Claims Association, usually called MCCA. That would be scrapped in favor of a new Michigan Catastrophic Care Corporation, which would cap medical coverage at $1 million.&nbsp;Once a severely injured person’s care hit that limit, they would be out of luck.&nbsp;</p><p> Wed, 24 Apr 2013 12:51:46 +0000 Jack Lessenberry 12265 at http://michiganradio.org Commentary: What price reform? In this morning's news: welfare drug tests, student achievement lags, ending lifetime coverage http://michiganradio.org/post/mornings-news-welfare-drug-tests-student-achievement-lags-ending-lifetime-coverage <p><strong>Drug tests for welfare recipients</strong><br><br>A bill which would require drug tests for welfare recipients has moved forward in the Michigan legislature.<br><br>"A state House panel yesterday sent the legislation to the full chamber. Under the bill, the state would have to have reasonable suspicion before requiring a test. Cash assistance benefits could be terminated for people who test positive," Jake Neher <a href="http://www.michiganradio.org/post/welfare-drug-testing-bill-moves-forward-state-house">reports.</a><br><br><strong>Student performance in Michigan falls behind</strong><br><br>"A new report from The Education Trust – Midwest says Michigan improved some aspects of student performance, but most other states improved even more between 2003 to 2011. The report says one reason Michigan fell behind is that the state’s strategy for improvement relied primarily on the expansion of charter and virtual schools," Michigan Radio's Dustin Dwyer reports.<br><br><strong>Ending unlimited coverage for auto accidents</strong><br><br>Governor Rick Snyder and GOP lawmakers are unveiling a proposal today to end unlimited lifetime coverage for medical expenses tied to auto accidents.<br><br>"The insurance lobby and other critics say Michigan's unique requirement for unlimited medical coverage is too expensive. Hospitals and others say it should stay intact," according to the Associated Press.</p><p> Thu, 18 Apr 2013 11:49:13 +0000 Michigan Radio Newsroom 12194 at http://michiganradio.org In this morning's news: welfare drug tests, student achievement lags, ending lifetime coverage What's behind the high costs of Michigan auto insurance rates? http://michiganradio.org/post/whats-behind-high-costs-michigan-auto-insurance-rates <p>Depending on where you live in the state, your auto insurance rates could be outrageously high.</p><p>During the last session of the Michigan Legislature, there was an attempt to change the state’s auto no-fault insurance with claims that it would lower rates.</p><p>This is something the auto insurance agencies keep lobbying for, and Governor Rick Snyder said in his State of the State address we need to keep costs down.<br><br>But there’s little evidence that your insurance rates would go down that much, or at all, by these limits.</p><p>That’s because the real reason auto insurance is so high in some areas is theft, fraud, and uninsured motorists.</p><p>The part of no-fault that guarantees someone severely hurt will get the reasonable care they need is just a fraction of the cost, and some would argue the best bargain in the nation.</p><p>Joining me now is a lawyer who, we should point out, fights the insurance companies over claims on a regular basis.</p><p>Steven Gursten is with the law firm <a href="http://www.michiganautolaw.com/">Michigan Auto Law</a>.</p><p>Most of us find auto insurance coverage a little confusing at best, so we started off by explaining what catastrophic coverage is, and what the Michigan Catastrophic Claims Association is.</p><p><em>Listen to the full interview above.</em></p><p> Tue, 12 Mar 2013 20:44:07 +0000 Stateside Staff 11627 at http://michiganradio.org What's behind the high costs of Michigan auto insurance rates? This morning's news: Gun sales, 'no-fault' insurance changes, and snowmobile event canceled http://michiganradio.org/post/mornings-news-gun-sales-no-fault-insurance-changes-and-snowmobile-event-canceled <p><strong>Political winds flame gun and ammo sales in Michigan</strong></p><p><span style="color: rgb(54, 54, 54); font-family: Georgia, serif; font-size: 16px; line-height: 24px;">President Obama called on Congress and the American public to support <a href="http://www.washingtonpost.com/national/obama-assault-weapons-have-no-place-on-streets/2013/02/04/49f71871-4cbb-4c4c-b0ce-29989a1f16c5_video.html">new gun control plans yesterday in Minneapolis</a>. While <a href="http://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/universal-background-checks-increasingly-popular-article-1.1255416">public support</a> for some kinds of gun control measures is up, others continue to stock up fearing coming gun restrictions.</span></p><p><span style="color: rgb(54, 54, 54); font-family: Georgia, serif; font-size: 16px; line-height: 24px;"><a href="http://www.mlive.com/news/grand-rapids/index.ssf/2013/02/out_of_stock_firearms_ammo_sal.html#incart_most-comments">MLive reports</a> gun and ammunition sales are surging as gun control political winds blow:</span></p><blockquote><p><span style="color: rgb(54, 54, 54); font-family: Georgia, serif; font-size: 16px; line-height: 24px;">In December, the FBI ran 59,445 background checks for guns sales in Michigan, the highest monthly total in the state since the database started in 1998. The second highest monthly total was October 2001 when the FBI ran 46,270 background checks.</span></p></blockquote><p><strong><span style="color: rgb(54, 54, 54); font-family: Georgia, serif; font-size: 16px; line-height: 24px;">Michigan leaders want changes to state's no-fault insurance</span></strong></p><p>If you're seriously injured in an automobile accident in Michigan, the current insurance laws in the state set you up with lifetime medical and rehabilitation coverage for your injuries. But state lawmakers want that changed.</p><p>This morning, the <a href="http://www.detroitnews.com/article/20130205/POLITICS02/302050347/No-fault-reform-fight-wings?odyssey=tab|topnews|text|FRONTPAGE">Detroit News</a> profiles Sam Howell. He's benefiting from the state's current insurance laws. The News points out why Gov. Snyder and other lawmakers think changes to the current system are necessary:</p><blockquote><p>Snyder says the reforms are necessary to rein in no-fault auto insurance rates in Michigan that rank among the highest in the country — particularly in Detroit — and tackle a $2 billion unfunded liability in the state's catastrophic auto accident fund the insurance industry says is unsustainable without severe cost controls.</p></blockquote><p>As <a href="http://www.michiganradio.org/post/seven-things-know-about-changes-michigans-mandatory-auto-insurance">Michigan Radio's Lester Graham</a> has reported, many things influence overall insurance rates in the state, and some argue if these benefits are capped, taxpayers will step in to foot the bill:</p><blockquote><p>Opponents also say capping injury benefits will force the most severely injured accident victims to turn to Medicaid and welfare once they reach the insurance cap and exhaust all their family resources. They estimate it will shift $30 million a year to taxpayers.</p></blockquote><p><strong><span style="color: rgb(54, 54, 54); font-family: Georgia, serif; font-size: 16px; line-height: 24px;">Snowmobile event in upper Michigan canceled in wake of Caleb Moore's death</span></strong></p><p>Michigan's Turtle Creek Casino and Hotel near Traverse City was planning to hold a snowmobile freestyle event this Friday and Saturday (Feb. 8 and 9), but the group overseeing the event has canceled in the wake of the <a href="http://www.usatoday.com/story/sports/olympics/2013/01/31/caleb-moore-dies-after-injuries-x-games-crash-snowmobile/1880587/">tragic death of snowmobile freestyler Caleb Moore</a>.</p><p>More from the <a href="http://www.freep.com/article/20130205/SPORTS18/130205014/Caleb-Moore-snowmobile-freestyle-Williamsburg">Detroit Free Press</a>:</p><blockquote><p>The ISOC, which overseas and promotes snocross racing with the AMSOIL Championship Snocross series, has also withdrawn snowmobile freestyle competition from Wisconsin's Lake Geneva Resort stop March 15-16.</p><p>Moore, 25, died in hospital from injuries suffered when his snowmobile landed on top of him after he crashed attempting a back flip on his 500-pound machine in men's snowmobile freestyle Jan. 24 in Aspen, Colo. It was the first death in the 18-year history of the X Games. Tue, 05 Feb 2013 14:16:46 +0000 Mark Brush 11091 at http://michiganradio.org This morning's news: Gun sales, 'no-fault' insurance changes, and snowmobile event canceled Body that manages state’s catastrophic claims fund fighting against court ruling http://michiganradio.org/post/body-manages-state-s-catastrophic-claims-fund-fighting-against-court-ruling <p>Lawmakers are getting ready to consider changes to the state’s no-fault auto insurance law.</p><p>At the same time a court battle over a fund that reimburses auto insurance companies for large claims continues.</p><p>When you file a personal injury claim in Michigan of more than a half-million dollars, your auto insurance company gets reimbursed by a state-created fund. It’s basically an insurance policy for insurers.</p><p>The fund that pays those reimbursements is facing a lawsuit that says it should provide more information about how it comes up with an annual fee that ultimately gets passed on to drivers. It’s appealing a circuit court decision saying that information is subject to public information requests.</p><p>Pete Kuhnmuench is with the Insurance Institute of Michigan, which supports the appeal.</p><p>“Literally 90 percent of what was required to be disclosed under the judge’s recent ruling is already out there for public consumption,” Kuhnmuench said.</p><p>Plaintiffs in the case say lawmakers need a complete picture as they weigh proposals to change the state’s no-fault law. Wed, 23 Jan 2013 17:26:25 +0000 Jake Neher 10900 at http://michiganradio.org Body that manages state’s catastrophic claims fund fighting against court ruling