Ann Arbor high school football players show better sportsmanship than coaches

Oct 19, 2012

Last week, the Ann Arbor Pioneer high school football team went across town to play long-time rival Ann Arbor Huron.  It wasn’t the players’ performance during the game that made news, however, but the coaches’ behavior afterward.  And the news wasn’t good.

Ann Arbor Pioneer came into the annual rivalry with Ann Arbor Huron, sporting a solid 4-3 record and a good chance to make the playoffs.  Huron hadn’t won a game all year, and was simply playing out the season.  The only stakes were bragging rights – and even those weren’t much in question.

With a minute left, Pioneer enjoyed an impressive 35-6 lead.  At that point, it’s customary for the winning coach to tell his team to run out the clock by taking a knee, instead of trying to score again.  But Pioneer threw a pass, and then another, and then another – one of them to the endzone – in a clear display of poor sportsmanship.  That was the night’s first mistake. 

This made Huron head coach Cory Gildersleeve apoplectic, yelling across the field to his counterpart, Pioneer head coach Paul Test, to knock it off. 

That was the second mistake made by the men that night.  If your team is getting crushed, and you’re the head coach, you don’t worry about the other guys.  You get your team to the locker room, and start working to get better. 

The game ended, and the players had no problem shaking hands, and saying, Good luck.  But not the head coaches.  At mid-field, Gildersleeve started pointing his finger and yelling at Paul Test – a coach I’ve known, and admired.  Test told Gildersleeve he didn’t call those plays – and that was the third mistake.  That simply doesn’t fly.  When you’re the head coach, you’re responsible for everything that your coaches and players do – and that certainly includes the plays your staff calls.  That answer was weak. 

Paul Test has a history of running up the score, and leaving bad feelings behind.  Just ask Dexter, which Pioneer beat 69-0 this year – after which, Pioneer’s players put one of their assistant coaches, who used to be the head coach at Dexter and still teaches there, on their shoulders, and marched him right in front of the Dexter bench, as if to ask, “How do ya like me now?” Dexter’s answer: Not very much, thank you.  But no fights broke out. 

The Huron-Pioneer game would’ve ended with some hard feelings, but nothing more – until an unnamed Pioneer assistant coach saw the two head coaches arguing, broke from the handshake line and ran up to Huron’s head coach.  It’s not clear whether he pushed Gildersleeve or punched him, but there’s no question he made contact.  A Pioneer player pulled his coach away, but the coach jumped right back in – and just like that, a bench-clearing brawl broke out.  Call those mistakes four and five. 

That’s the bad news.  The good news is just about everything that followed. No students rushed the field.  The players, for the most part, were trying to break things up with the exception of a few.  The schools’ athletic directors – both women – bravely jumped into the middle and helped end the melee.  Since then, everybody has apologized, and both teams’ captains have met to mend the fences.

Both head coaches received two game suspensions – one from the state, and one from the district. A few players will also be suspended for the next game for their role in the brawl, which for the Pioneers, could be costly, as they push for the playoffs.  Perhaps most important, the offending Pioneer assistant coach, who seems to have absolutely no idea what high school sports are supposed to teach, has been fired.  Good. 

But when I take a step back, I’m struck most by who started it, and who ended it.  I can only hope that the men who run these teams start acting more like the women who supervise them and the teenagers who play for them.

That night, it was women and children first.  The men finished last.