WUOMFM

Lifted On Giant Inner Tubes, An Old Tree Moves In Michigan

Originally published on October 27, 2014 8:42 am

For as many as 250 years, a bur oak has been growing on what is now the University of Michigan campus in Ann Arbor. The big tree stands in the way of an expansion of the Ross Business School.

But instead of cutting it down, the university is moving the tree. It's not easy, it's not cheap, and it's definitely not fast.

As it was prepared for its 500-foot trip down a pedestrian mall, the old oak's 44-foot diameter root ball was wrapped in plastic and burlap and rested on long pipes, inserted earlier this summer to create a platform for lifting.

"While it does look fairly radical and invasive — and it is — if it's done properly, chances of survival are fantastic," says Paul Cox of Environmental Design, one of the few companies able to move a tree that weighs about 700,000 pounds.

The tree was raised on huge rubber bags so transporters could slip underneath. The bags look like inner tubes, except much thicker and longer.

"You first place these bags, deflated, beneath the tree, beneath the pipe, and then slowly inflate them, and as you inflate, the tree comes up into the air," Cox explains.

All this know-how, labor and equipment is expensive. The move will cost about $400,000, money that came from $100 million donated for the expansion by philanthropist Stephen Ross, for whom the business school was renamed.

University spokesman Rick Fitzgerald says the school has never moved a tree this large before.

"We didn't know if it could be moved," Fitzgerald says. "We started exploring options, and come to find out there are companies that do this and have been successfully moving large trees for decades."

Fitzgerald admits the plan doesn't please everybody. Some business school students say it's too much money to save one tree. Some also say they don't like the new location, blocking part of the view of the front entrance.

Even BJ Smith, a forester who drove all the way from west Michigan to watch this move, can't make a good business case for it.

"For the same price, I think in Washtenaw County, [where Ann Arbor is located] you can get about 120 acres of forested land," Smith says. "That might be a better legacy than one tree."

Nevertheless, he watched in awe as the big inner tubes deflated and the tree was lowered onto the transporters. It made its way at a pace of about 1 mph to its new home on the other side of the business school.

The tree should be placed in the ground sometime Sunday, where it may live, easily, for another 250 years.

Copyright 2014 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

RACHEL MARTIN, HOST:

An old Bur Oak tree growing on the University of Michigan campus has been around since America's Revolutionary War. But the big tree stands in the way of an expansion of the business school there. Instead of cutting it down, the tree is being relocated. As Michigan Radio's Tracy Samilton reports, the move isn't easy. It's not cheap, and it is definitely not fast.

TRACY SAMILTON, BYLINE: The old Bur Oak tree is ready to be moved. It's 44-feet-in-diameter root ball, wrapped in plastic and burlap, is resting on long metal pipes.

PAUL COX: While it does look fairly radical and invasive - and it is - if it's done properly, chances of survival are fantastic.

SAMILTON: That is Paul Cox of Environmental Design, one of the few companies that can move a tree that weighs about 700,000 pounds. It will have to be raised so transporters can slip underneath. That's what the company's huge, rubber bags are for. They look like inner tubes, except much thicker and longer.

COX: You first place these bags deflated beneath the tree, beneath the pipe and then slowly inflate them. And as you inflate, the tree comes up into the air.

SAMILTON: All this know-how labor and equipment is costly. The move will cost about $400,000. Now that money is not coming out of the university's budget. It's coming out of the $100 million donated for the expansion by philanthropist Steven Ross. The business school was also renamed for him, by the way. But anyway, money like that still doesn't grow on trees. Rick Fitzgerald is a spokesman for the U of M.

RICK FITZGERALD: We didn't know if it could be moved. And we started exploring options. And come to find out, there are companies that do this and have been successfully moving large trees for decades.

SAMILTON: And after some back and forth, the consensus was this is an institution of higher learning, and this is certainly a learning opportunity.

FITZGERALD: Because we've - at the University of Michigan, we've never moved a tree like this before.

SAMILTON: Fitzgerald admits it's probably a case of please all, all please none. There's always people who get upset to see a tree cut down in its prime. And some business school students told us it's too much money for one tree. Or they don't like the new location; blocking part of the view of the front entrance. Even BJ Smith, a forrester who drove all the way from West Michigan to watch this move, can't make a good business case for it.

BJ SMITH: For the same price, I think, in Washtenaw County, you can get about 120 acres of forested land. And that might be a better legacy than one tree.

SAMILTON: But then again, he is here watching in awe as the big inner tubes deflate, the tree is lowered onto the transporters, and it makes its way at a pace of about one mile an hour to its new home on the other side of the business school. The tree should be placed in the ground sometime today where it could live, easily, for another 250 years or so. For NPR News, I'm Tracy Samilton in Ann Arbor.

MARTIN: This is NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.